Amazon, the e-commerce giant, has announced a new fee structure for third-party sellers who ship their products to customers without utilizing the company’s fulfillment service. Effective October 1, Amazon will take a 2% cut or a minimum of $0.25 per item from vendors using its Seller Fulfilled Prime Program. This announcement comes at a time when the company faces significant scrutiny from regulators and sellers alike.

Seller Fulfilled Prime Program and Its Impact

Launched in 2015, the Seller Fulfilled Prime Program allowed vendors to exhibit the Prime badge on their listings without using Amazon’s Fulfillment by Amazon service. In exchange, sellers had to ensure one-day and two-day delivery to Prime customers at no extra charge.

The program was suspended temporarily due to quality issues but was reopened two months ago. The new fee is specifically aimed at merchants who use this program to manage logistics themselves. These often include sellers of larger items like furniture that may not fit well within Amazon’s highly automated warehouses.

A Coercive Tactic?

The move has drawn sharp criticism from various quarters, especially merchants who view it as unexpected and coercive. Some retailers perceive this new cost as an attempt to push them into using Amazon’s logistical services. One furniture merchant even estimated that the fee could cost his company approximately $1 million annually, forcing him to utilize Amazon’s services, as leaving the platform is not feasible considering Amazon’s vast customer base.

Amazon Anywhere AR shopping

Amazon’s Increasing Control

Amazon’s control over its platform and the 2 million businesses that rely on it has often been the subject of scrutiny. With approximately 37.6% of all online spending in the United States, Amazon’s market power is nearly six times more than its nearest online competitor, Walmart Inc.

The new fee comes on top of the existing 15% commission that merchants pay as part of selling on the platform. This, coupled with the increasing cost for advertising and shipping, has made it increasingly challenging for sellers to maintain profitability on Amazon’s platform.

The Federal Trade Commission is planning an antitrust action against Amazon, and this move caught many merchants and consultants by surprise. Bloomberg quoted Jason Boyce, CEO of Avenue7Media, stating, “this fee shows Amazon is not scared at all.”

An Expanding Revenue Stream

Seller services generated $32.3 billion in the second quarter, up 18% from the previous year, overtaking even Amazon’s successful cloud services sector. Seller fees have become a significant part of Amazon’s revenue structure, encompassing nearly half of each transaction’s cost.

Conclusion: A Strategic Dilemma

Amazon’s imposition of new fees on third-party sellers is a complex and strategic move. While it seems to align with the company’s ongoing efforts to centralize its logistical processes and increase revenue from seller services, it raises critical concerns about market power, competition, and vendor relationships.

The move may be seen as a strategic attempt to standardize the Prime delivery experience. Still, it also risks further straining Amazon’s relationship with its third-party sellers and attracting additional regulatory attention.

The timing and nature of this change emphasize the delicate balance Amazon must maintain as it continues to expand its marketplace while navigating the intricate web of relationships, expectations, and regulations that govern its vast ecosystem.

As Amazon’s influence grows, so does the scrutiny and expectation for transparency and fair practices. The response to this new fee structure may well serve as a litmus test for Amazon’s ability to adapt and respond to the evolving needs and concerns of its diverse array of stakeholders.